Update 1.3.0
Since update 1.3.0 each of the 12 fishing waters on 10 islands has its own loot table. Cast where the item you want has the biggest share.
Both the Fishing Rod and the Fishing Drone draw from the loot table of the water they fish in (verified in-game). Percentages are each item's share of that table; whether a cast yields loot at all is decided separately.
Fishing is the only way to get these items — no recipe, lootchest, trade, harvest or Lost Cargo gives them.
Best: Worm — 4.2%
Best: Worm — 4.2%
Best: Worm — 4.2%
Best: Worm — 4.2%
Best: Pepperbend — 51% · also Island 1 51%, Island 15 51%, Worm 17%, Wild Winter 32%
Best: Sunfall Basin — 11%
Best: Sunfall Basin — 11% · also Mossback Hollow 10%, Haven 9.5%, Twinfall 8.3%, Wild Winter 3.2%, Pepperbend 2.6%, Island 1 2.6%, Island 15 2.6%
Best: Haven — 24% · also Sunfall Basin 11%, Mossback Hollow 10%, Twinfall 8.3%, Wheatwater 7.9%
Best: Worm — 4.2% · also Wheatwater 2.4%
Best: Worm — 4.2% · also Wheatwater 2.4%
Best: Worm — 4.2% · also Wheatwater 2.4%
Best: Worm — 4.2% · also Wheatwater 2.4%
Best: Wild Winter — 3.2% · also Pepperbend 2.6%, Island 1 2.6%, Island 15 2.6%
Best: Wild Winter — 24% · also Worm 4.2%
Best: Mossback Hollow — 50% · also Worm 42%, Twinfall 42%, Wheatwater 39%, Pepperbend 38%, Island 1 38%, Island 15 38%, Haven 38%, Wild Winter 32%, Sunfall Basin 22%
Best: Wild Winter — 3.2% · also Pepperbend 2.6%, Island 1 2.6%, Island 15 2.6%
Best: Sunfall Basin — 11% · also Mossback Hollow 10%, Haven 9.5%, Twinfall 8.3%, Worm 8.3%, Wheatwater 7.9%
Best: Twinfall — 17% · also Sunfall Basin 11%, Wheatwater 7.9%, Worm 4.2%
Best: Sunfall Basin — 11% · also Mossback Hollow 10%, Haven 9.5%, Twinfall 8.3%, Wheatwater 7.9%, Wild Winter 3.2%, Pepperbend 2.6%, Island 1 2.6%, Island 15 2.6%
Best: Sunfall Basin — 11% · also Mossback Hollow 10%, Worm 8.3%, Haven 9.5%, Twinfall 8.3%, Wheatwater 7.9%
Best: Twinfall — 8.3%
Best: Wheatwater — 12%
Water 1
Water 2
Water 1
Water 2
